Flamur Hoxha

The country is heading towards a Greek-style debt crisis

Translated from Albanian. Read the original

Flamur Hoxha speaking in Parliament on public debt

Honourable citizens, fellow MPs

Today we are debating a number of changes to VAT, some changes to excise duty and the draft budget for 2022.

Before reading the draft budget, I read once again your government programme for the third term, in which the main points included, among others:

Well-being for all; modernisation for the development of the productive economy, agriculture, tourism and economic digitalisation; a strong Albania; reduction of public debt.

I read the draft budget and see that projected economic growth for 2022 is 4.1% above last year, with a nominal GDP of 15.3 billion euros, where nominal GDP is forecast to increase in value by 804 million euros, while the budget deficit will rise by 5.4% of GDP, meaning public debt will increase by 827 million euros. In 2022 too, as over the last 8 years, the Albanian government continues to increase public debt faster than GDP.

I believe it is clear to everyone that Albanians’ money is being squandered and the country is heading towards a Greek-style debt crisis.

The government declared well-being and development in its programme, yet on the other hand the education budget is only 2.6% of GDP, compared with over 5% in developed countries, or with the 3.3% under the right-wing government in 2013.

Education’s share of the budget is 7.25%, while Kosovo, the youngest state in the region, dedicates 14% of its budget to education, and the regional average is above 12%.

How is a country’s economic development to be achieved when the education budget is cut year after year?! Not to forget here the cut to the budget for vocational secondary education: -1.8 million euros (-23%), and for sport and youth development: -0.9 million euros (-28%). By ruining education and scorning knowledge, the country’s future is surely ruined.

Last week the Bank of Albania spoke of a wave of inflation that will continue into the first months of 2022. To face this situation, the government, which as stated in its programme has well-being at the heart of development, decides to index inflation into the excise duty on alcohol from 1 January 2022, and we suppose it is right to do so since budget revenue will increase. But what is being done for the consumer??? Why not also index wages to inflation from 1 January?!

It declares there will be wage increases, but for the few professions that will have their wages indexed (an extra 20 million euros in the budget, which is little or nothing), the increase will only take effect on 1 July 2022. What will these people do for the first 6 months, or will they have to tighten their belts?

And not stopping there, it raises the excise duty on gas for household consumption by 6 lek, thereby imposing extra costs on households and businesses. Of course this may lead to a reduction in evasion, but it is happening at the expense of poor consumers and businesses, all the more so in a situation of energy crisis. The more a government impoverishes a people, the more secure its rule.

As for pensioners, a good part of whom receive pensions below the subsistence minimum, there has been no thought of raising pensions; there will simply be an indexation for inflation. The discrimination and contempt for the elderly continues, by law.

The government considers agriculture and raising its productivity a priority in its programme, and what does it do about it? To start with, it cuts this sector’s budget by 2% compared with 2021. By penalising agriculture, it penalises competitive domestic production, and we continue to buy imported food and send around 700 million euros abroad for food.

More specifically, it proposes raising the value of investment in machinery tenfold, to over 500 million lek (it was over 50 million), in order to qualify for the VAT exemption on imported machinery. Deciding that the VAT exemption applies only if the investment in machinery exceeds 4 million euros practically hinders investment in technology and, even more, holds back new investors. The negative effects of this measure are also indirect, because it will help hold back productivity growth, which is one of the main problems of our country.

It has also been proposed that the VAT compensation scheme for farmers be reduced to zero. It was 20%, was lowered to 6% two years ago, and now it is proposed that it become 0. According to the government, the best solution to the scheme’s problems is apparently to abolish the compensation, damaging the agro-processing sector and farmers, increasing imports (processors will turn to imports) and raising prices in future. How is this sector a priority when both the farmer and the agro-processor are discriminated against? As regards support for agriculture and the farmer, let us not invent things; let us follow European models and support an increase in the number of livestock and in the number of fruit trees such as olives, since we still very much need to increase the areas planted and the numbers of trees and animals.

The exemption for agricultural inputs (chemical fertilisers, pesticides, seeds and seedlings) is removed and VAT is imposed at 10%. How will the additional costs be reimbursed to the farmer? How is agriculture, or Open Balkan, a priority when we raise the costs of this sector while all the countries of the region subsidise it? The budget for rural development has likewise been cut by -2.7 million euros (-9%), and forest administration by -0.8 million euros (-56%). We will have neither competitive agriculture nor a competitive economy if we do not subsidise as much as our neighbours, if not more.

Where is the growth in well-being, when prices rise but a partial reduction of VAT on the consumer basket is refused?

Where are the young, when there are zero funds for their employment or for financing policies to keep young people in the country?

Where is enterprise, when the new 2022 fiscal package is projected to generate an extra 5.27 billion lek for the 2022 state budget, but this money, like the public debt, will go to concessions and to building roads at the most expensive prices in the world, in the country with the lowest wages in Europe?

Thank you